The Science of Leading
All Episodes
Retention Is Decided Before Day One

Retention Is Decided Before Day One

0:00|0:00

Most companies treat hiring and retention as two separate programs, run by two separate teams. But many of the people who leave in their first months were lost before they ever started, in the job ad, the interview pitch and the channel they were hired through. Claire and Edwin look at how retention gets decided during hiring, and what to change first.


Chapter 1

Imported Transcript

Claire Monroe

Welcome to the show everybody! I'm Claire Monroe, here with Edwin Carrington. Edwin, most companies run hiring and retention as two separate programs. One team fills the seats, another team tries to keep people in them. But I came across a survey that makes me question that split. In a 2018 survey, BambooHR asked about a thousand U.S. workers and found that thirty one percent had quit a job within the first six months. And among the top reasons: they'd changed their minds about the job, and the work was different from what they expected.

Edwin Carrington

Different from what they expected. That phrase tells you where the problem started, Claire. Not in month five. In the interview. If the work turned out different from what someone expected, then somebody set that expectation. Usually us.

Claire Monroe

So retention isn't something you fix after the hire. It's something you decide during it.

Edwin Carrington

That's exactly how I'd put it. Hiring and retention aren't two programs. They're one decision, made twice. Once when you choose the person, and again every month they decide whether to stay. And the second decision is shaped by everything you said and did during the first.

Claire Monroe

Let's start with the pitch, then. Because there's real pressure to sell the job. You're competing for good people.

Edwin Carrington

There is, and that's where the damage starts. The recruiter wants to close. The hiring manager wants the seat filled. So the hard parts of the job get softened. The difficult client becomes a growth opportunity. The weekend on-call rotation becomes occasional flexibility. And the candidate accepts a job that doesn't exist. Then they meet the real one.

Claire Monroe

There's research on the alternative, which is called a realistic job preview. David Earnest, David Allen and Ronald Landis published a meta-analysis in Personnel Psychology in 2011, covering fifty-two studies and about seventeen thousand people. Realistic job previews were linked to lower turnover. I'll be honest, the effect was small. But the interesting part was why it worked. The one mechanism that mattered was whether people saw the organization as honest.

Edwin Carrington

That's the real finding, Claire, and it's more important than the size of the effect. People don't need a perfect job. Nobody expects one. What they can't forgive is discovering they were misled. Tell a candidate the hard parts up front, and two things happen. The people who can't live with them opt out before they cost you anything. And the people who join trust you, because you told them the truth when it would have been easier not to.

Claire Monroe

So the honest job ad is a retention tool.

Edwin Carrington

It may be the cheapest retention tool you have. Describe the real work, the real pace and the real pressure. If that shrinks your applicant pool, it's shrinking it in the right places.

Claire Monroe

The second piece is where people come from. Some hiring channels produce people who stay, and some produce people who leave. Stephen Burks, Bo Cowgill, Mitchell Hoffman and Michael Housman studied nine large firms in call centers, trucking and high tech, published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics in 2015. Workers hired through employee referrals quit noticeably less often than other hires, across all three industries.

Edwin Carrington

That doesn't surprise me. A referral comes with an honest job preview built in. The friend who referred them already told them what the job is really like.

Claire Monroe

And there was a twist. At the one firm where they could match referrers to their own performance, referrals from strong performers were the most profitable hires. But referrals from weaker performers could actually do worse than hiring with no referral at all.

Edwin Carrington

Which tells you that who refers matters as much as whether they refer. Your best people tend to refer people who work the way they do. So here's the practical step. Track first-year retention and performance by source. Referral, job board, agency, campus. Most companies track cost per hire by channel. Very few track how long each channel's hires actually stay. That second number tells you where to spend.

Claire Monroe

And the third piece is the assessment itself.

Edwin Carrington

Yes. If the people who leave early are leaving because the job didn't fit how they operate, then you have to measure that before the offer, not discover it after. A work history tells you where someone has been. An unstructured interview tells you how well they talk about it. Neither tells you how they're wired to operate under the specific pressure of this role.

Claire Monroe

And that’s where behavioral data fits in the process.

Edwin Carrington

It is. A validated behavioral assessment shows how someone tends to operate under the kind of pressure the role brings. Compare candidates with the people who already succeed and stay in that role, not with a generic idea of a good hire. And it’s one structured input, never the sole basis for a decision.

Claire Monroe

And then onboarding is where the second half of that one decision happens.

Edwin Carrington

Exactly. Treat the first ninety days as the end of the hiring process, not the start of employment. Agree on checkpoints at thirty, sixty and ninety days. Ask directly, at each one: is this the job you expected? That single question surfaces the gap while you can still close it.

Claire Monroe

If you want to see what the people who succeed and stay in a role have in common, start with the one you trust most. OAD's free Top Performer Profile takes seven minutes, results come back in twenty-four hours, and there's no credit card. That's O-A-D dot A-I.

Edwin Carrington

Most people decide to leave long before they resign, Claire. The best companies make sure they decided to stay before they started.

Claire Monroe

Perfect place to leave it. Thanks for the wisdom, Edwin.

Edwin Carrington

Always a pleasure, Claire.